Keep Your Starter Crankin'
Article from Skinned Knuckles Magazine
by Frank Pennypacker
Does Your Starter Have the Power It Needs?
When you press the starter switch, push the starter button or turn the key, you expect to hear a vigorous rah-rah-rah-rah and then the engine starts. Sometimes, the response is a very sluggish raaaah-raaaah-raaaah-raaaah or else nothing but a click, and you know that the starter isn't working like you expect, and you need to fix it.
This article was inspired by some discussions about starting problems in several on line forums by various car clubs. Often, neither the persons asking the questions nor the persons providing the answers understand exactly how much voltage and current are necessary to power a starter. This article explains what you need to do to be sure that the starter is getting the electrical power it needs to generate the mechanical power needed to crank the engine.
There are several important points to keep in mind. First, a starter is an electric motor that converts electric power from the battery into mechanical power that will crank the engine. Second, the starter must have sufficient electrical power available in order to generate the necessary mechanical power. And third, it takes a lot of power to crank an engine; the current required is in the hundreds of amps. Now, to the details.
You need to know some electrical fundamentals to understand how a starter system works.
In a direct current (DC) circuit, there are three quantities: current, voltage and resistance.
Current is the rate of flow of electricity and it is measured in amperes, usually called amps. Voltage, measured in volts, is the electrical pressure that makes the current flow. Resistance, measured in ohms, is what limits current flow, the electrical equivalent of friction.
Ohm's law gives the relationship between current (I), voltage (V) and resistance (R). There are three forms of Ohm's law. The three forms are equivalent and any of the three forms can be gotten from any other using algebra. All three forms are given here for convenience.
- I = V/R Current in amps equals voltage in volts divided by resistance in ohms.
- R = V/I Resistance equals voltage divided by current
- V = R * I Voltage equals resistance times current
If you know two of the quantities, you can calculate the third by using Ohm's law.
Figure 1 shows a simple circuit. Here a battery provides 6 volts that moves cutTent through a 0.02 ohm resistance. The current is 6 volts divided by 0.02 ohms or 300 amps.
Energy and Power
Energy is the ability to do work or to create heat. Energy can have many forms. One form is mechanical energy, the ability to move an object against a force resisting that motion, or electrical energy, the ability to move electricity through a circuit against the electrical resistance of that circuit.
Power is the rate of energy flow, and each form of energy has a corresponding form of power. A unit of mechanical power is the horsepower, which is the power required to move an object 550 feet per second against a resistance of 1 pound. The unit of electrical power is the watt, which is the power to move 1 ampere with a voltage of 1 volt.
Mechanical power can be converted to electrical power using a generator or alternator. Electrical power can be converted to mechanical power using an electric motor. If the conversion could be done with 100 % efficiency, 746 watts would convert to 1 horsepower or 1 horsepower would convert to 746 watts. The conversion cannot be done with 100 % efficiency because some of the electrical power is lost moving the electricity through a generator's or motor's electrical conductors, and some of the mechanical energy is lost overcoming friction. The lost power becomes heat.
To calculate electrical power:
P=V * I Power (in watts) equals voltage (in volts) times current (in amps)
In the Figure 1 circuit, power equals 6 volts times 300 amps, or 1,800 watts. Since the circuit is a resistor which converts electrical energy to heat, the entire 1800 watts is converted to heat.
A starter is a motor that converts electrical power from a battery to mechanical power to crank an engine. Current flows through field coils that produce a magnetic field. Current also flows through windings in the armature. This current in the armature interacts with the magnetic field to produce force which creates torque that will tum the armature. The torque is proportional to the current in the armature. As the armature turns, its motion generates a voltage, which subtracts from the voltage supplied by the battery and decreases the armature cur rent and the torque.
The Starter System
Figure 2 shows a starter system consisting of a battery, a starter, a starter switch and cables. In order to determine the voltages and current, it is necessary to know the electrical characteristics of the battery, the starter and the cables.
It is difficult to get starter specifications for antique cars. Starters were purchased parts; the automobile manufacturer did not make the starters. Specifications were negotiated between the parts suppliers and the manufacturers and were not generally published. I have found specifications for starters made by North East Electric Company (merged with Delco in 1929), Atwater Kent (no longer in business) and Delco-Remy. Since these starters have similar specifications, one of them will be the basis for a 'typical' starter to be used as an example.
These starters were used with 1920's engines of about 200 cubic inches with compression ratios of about 4: 1. After determining the voltages and current necessary to power the example starter, I will discuss starters for other engines.
It is important to supply the high current that the starter draws before it starts rotating to allow the starter to develop the high torque to get rotation started. The example starter is rated to draw a current of 590 amps at 3.1 volts with the shaft locked (not rotating). The following calculations are for the peak current condition when the starter is first energized.
Using the second version of Ohm's law:
R= V /I
Resistance equals voltage divided by current The starter has a resistance of 3.1 volts divided by 590 amps, which is 0.00525 ohms.
Automotive batteries are designed to produce the large current required for the few seconds usually required to start an engine and are rated for "Cranking Amps." But, when the battery is producing hundreds of amps, its volt age will decrease to much less than the nominal 6 volts or 12 volts. The cranking amps rating means that at 32 degrees F, the battery will produce that many amps without its voltage drop ping below 1.2 volts per cell for 30 seconds. A 6 volt battery has three cells and is rated to produce cranking amps with at least 3.6 volts and a 12 volt battery, with six cells, is rated to produce cranking amps with at least 7.2 volts. The battery in the example is a 6 volt battery rated for more than 600 cranking amps.
The resistance of the cables depends on the size of the cables and their length. Table 1 shows diameters and resistances of copper wire from 0000 gauge (also called 4/0 gauge) through 6 gauge. Diameters shown are for stranded wire which is usually used for battery cables. Stranded wire is larger than solid wire because there is a small amount of space between the strands.
There are three cables in the example starter system: from the battery to the starter switch (1), from the switch to the starter (2) and from the battery to the ground connection on the transmission (3). In some vehicles, the battery is grounded to the chassis and there is a cable from the chassis to the engine block It is necessary to calculate the total resistance of all the cables. The total length of the cables in the example is 7.6 feet and the cables are 0 gauge From the wire table, 0 gauge cable has 0.0000983 ohms per foot. 7.6 feet of O gauge cable has 0.00075 ohms resistance.
The other component of the starter system is the switch. When the switch is open, the resistance is essentially infinite, so no current flows. When the switch is closed, the resistance of the switch is much less than the resistance of the cables and the current that flows depends only on the battery, the cables and the starter.
The calculation of voltages and currents is only approximate. Battery voltage and cur rent will vary with temperature, the charge state of the battery and the age of the battery. You can use this approximation to troubleshoot the system, with the understanding that it is an approximation. It should be understood that the calculated voltages and currents are for the brief time that the starter and engine are not turning. Once the starter begins to rotate and crank the engine, before the air-fuel mixture is ignited and the engine turns itself, the starter current will decrease and voltages will increase. When the air-fuel mixture in the cylinders starts to ignite and the engine turns itself, the starter will disengage from the engine and the current will be shut off
The calculation for total resistance is:
Resistance of Starter – 0.00525
+ Resistance of Cables – 0.00075
Total Resistance – 0.00600 ohms
Using Ohm's Law:
Current Through Starter = 3.6 Volts / 0.00600 ohms = 600 amps
Voltage Across Starter = 600 amps* 0.00525 ohms = 3.15 volts
Now, this is the state before the starter starts to rotate; the battery voltage is 3.6 volts while the battery is producing 600 amps, there is a 0.45 volt drop across the cables and the starter receives 3.15 volts. Once the starter is rotating and cranking the engine, the starter will generate voltage that opposes the battery voltage, the current will drop and the voltage across the starter will rise to 4.5 to 5 volts.
It can be difficult to get starter specifications, and these specifications are needed to calculate voltages and cmTents for your starter system. Here are some suggestions: ask other owners of similar models of the same make of car, consult on-line forums for your make of car, consult libraries and archives of clubs. (The starter information used in this article came from the H. H. Franklin club archives.) If the engine is similar to that of the example, the volt ages and currents are likely to be similar; how ever if the engine is larger or smaller, the cur rent can be scaled while the voltages will be about the same, and the cranking amps rating of recommended batteries will be a clue. Since batteries only last a few years, your battery was likely manufactured in the last few years and you should be able to get the battery cranking amps rating from the battery manufacturer.
Diesel engines require more cranking power than comparable gasoline engines.
Vehicles with 6 volt systems will have about the same voltages as the example, if the battery has adequate cranking amps and the cables have low enough resistance. Vehicles with 12 volt systems will have about twice the voltages as the example, assuming that the batteries and cables are adequate, that is locked rotor voltage of about 6.3 volts and cranking voltages about 9 to 10 volts.
In the wide world of vehicles with gasoline and diesel engines, there are starters that do not work as described, but this covers most of them.
Knowing the voltages to expect makes it possible to compare actual voltages with expected voltages. And this will allow isolating the problem. If there is enough voltage at the starter and the cranking is still sluggish, this indicates that the starter itself has a problem. You'll need to either have it rebuilt or replace it. If the battery voltage is low, the battery needs to be either charged or replaced. Caution: operating a starter for more than 15 seconds can cause overheating.
Replacing the Battery
If you need to get a new battery, it's best to find out the locked rotor cranking amps of the starter and buy a battery that will supply that many amps. Locked rotor amps are what it takes to produce the maximum torque to get the engine turning. If you have a choice of batteries, the one with more capacity is probably better, if it will fit. A battery's capacity can be test ed by measuring its voltage while operating the starter.
Replacing the Cables
When replacing cables, it's best to know the locked rotor cranking amps. Do not rely on the cables in a vehicle being the connect gauge.
If the vehicle is several decades old. the cables might have been replaced with smaller ones. Smaller cables have too much resistance. and high resistance causes a high voltage drop that reduces voltage and ClllTent for the starter causing sluggish starting. The voltage drop in the cable should be less than 0.5 volts in a 6 volt system and less than 1 volt in a 12 volt system. If you know the locked rotor starting current. you can determine what gauge cable you need using the wire table.
Determining the Wire Gauge:
Using Ohm's law:
Maximum resistance = 0.5 volt/locked rotor amps (for a 6 volt system)
Maximum resistance = 1 volt/locked rotor amps (for a 12 volt system)
Measure the cables from both battery terminals to the starter to determine the total length. Maximum ohms per foot=maximum resistance / total length. Pick a cable gauge from the wire table (fable 1) that has less than the maximum ohms per foot.
You can also use the wire table to deter mine the gauge of the cable installed in a vehicle by measuring the diameter of the conductor (do not measure the diameter of the insulation) and comparing it to the diameters listed in the wire table.
Test the cables by measuring the voltage drop while operating the starter.
Battery cables should not be aluminum. Since aluminum has a higher resistivity than copper. aluminum wire needs to be 2 gauges larger to have the same resistance as copper. It's difficult to make a reliable low resistance connection to aluminum wire.
If knowledge is power. this knowledge should help you make sure that your starter is getting the power it needs.
TROUBLESHOOTING A STARTER MOTOR
Considering how many times you start your car. day after day. month after month. the starter motor is a pretty reliable piece of machinery. Essentially it is nothing more than an electric motor which is activated when the driver turns the key to ‘START' or steps on the floor starter switch. The motor spins. turning a retractable gear on the end of the shaft. When activated. that gear engages with the teeth of the flywheel and spins the flywheel. moving the pistons up and down and allowing the engine to start on its own. Normally the starter motor requires no special attention or maintenance.
Although the starter motor might experience internal electrical problems – a bad field coil or a damaged armature – most of the problems are relatively simple to repair.
STARTER DOESN'T WORK AT ALL OR GRINDS OR CRANKS VERY SLOWLY
- Check battery – a dead or weak battery is the most likely cause.
- Check cables– loose or corroded cables will not permit adequate current to operate starter. Remember that a six-volt electrical system requires much larger cables than does a twelve-volt system. Use cables of no less than 'o'gauge - 'oo' or even 'ooo' are better – with a six-volt system.
- Check connections – loose connections at the battery. starter switch or starter motor – or even at ground – will prevent the starter· from operating.
- Check internal electrical – a starter motor shop can check your starter motor to determine if a field coil is broken or if the armature or commutator is shorted.
STARTER CLICKS BUT DOESN'T TURN
- Check solenoid (on newer cars) – the electrical contacts in the solenoid sometimes stick. Many solenoids are readily replaceable.
- Battery voltage is too low – charge the battery or use a 'donor' battery or a battery 'jump' to increase voltage.
STARTER WORKS OCCASIONALLY
- Check commutator – chances are there is a dead spot on the commutator. When that spot is under a brush, the motor will not operate.
- Check brushes – a loose, damaged or worn brush will occasionally fail to make adequate contact with the armature.
- Check flywheel – a chipped or broken tooth on the flywheel will cause failure when that tooth engages with the starter gear.
STARTER SPINS BUT ENGINES DOES NOT CRANK
- Check starter motor gear – the gear assembly (generally a Bendix assembly) is not engaging with the flywheel. Replacement Bendix assemblies are generally available.
- Flywheel teeth are stripped – rather far fetched, but still a remote possibility.
How the Pinion Works
When the starter motor spins, the pinion is engaged and the gear turns the flywheel. When the motor starts, the flywheel turns faster than the pinion and it forces the pinion to slide along the shaft, out of engagement.
Originally printed in Skinned Knuckles magazine, and copyrighted by SK Publishing/Skinned Knuckles Magazine. Reprinting of any portion prohibited without written permission of SK Publishing, PO Box 6983, Huntington Beach, CA 92615.
Subscriptions to Skinned Knuckles magazine is $28.00 for twelve monthly issues (within the U.S.). Contact Skinned Knuckles by mail at PO Box 6983, Huntington Beach, CA 92615; Website skinnedknuckles.net and click on Subscribe or PayPal. E-mail firstname.lastname@example.org, phone: 714-963-1558.